Skip to content

Stars and Wishes: how to get honest feedback from your D&D players

"Did everyone have fun?" gets a yes every time and tells you nothing. Stars and Wishes is a five-minute round at the end of a session that gets specific answers instead, and a short anonymous survey catches what nobody will say out loud. Both are below, ready to copy.

· 7 min read

What Stars and Wishes is

Stars and Wishes is a feedback round for the end of a tabletop RPG session. Everyone who played, the game master included, gives a star: one thing from the session they loved, whether a moment, something another player did, or a part of the game itself. Then everyone makes a wish: one thing they would like to see in a future session. That is the whole tool.

It was created by Lu Quade, who wrote it up on The Gauntlet’s blog in August 2018 as an alternative to Roses and Thorns, a round already in wide use in which a thorn names something that went badly. The change is in the second half. A thorn is a complaint about something that already happened; a wish is a request about what happens next. The same information reaches the DM, and nobody has had to tell a friend that their scene dragged.

It is not specific to D&D or to any system, and it has spread well beyond the community it came from: by 2020 it had been included in the TTRPG Safety Toolkit.

How to run Stars and Wishes at a D&D table

Run it straight after the last line of the session, before experience, loot or the calendar, while the night is still vivid. It takes about five minutes for a table of five.

  1. Say what you are doing in one sentence the first time: "one thing you loved tonight, one thing you would like to see in a future session".
  2. Go round for stars. One each, and it has to be specific: a moment, a line, a choice someone made. "The fight" is not a star; "when Mara held the door" is.
  3. Go round again for wishes. For your character, for the party, for the story, or for how the table plays.
  4. Take your own turn. A DM who gives a star to a player and makes a wish of their own is taking part, not collecting a report.
  5. Write the wishes down as they are said, in the player’s words.
  6. Do not answer a wish on the night. No explaining, no defending, no promising. "Got it" is the right reply.

Stars and Wishes card (read it out, or paste it in the group chat)

STARS AND WISHES

STAR: one thing from tonight you loved.
  A moment, a scene, something another player did,
  something the DM did. Name it.

WISH: one thing you would like to see in a future session.
  For your character, for the party, for the story,
  or for how we play.

Everyone gives both, the DM included.
Nobody answers a wish tonight. The DM writes them down.

What to do with a wish

A wish that goes nowhere teaches the table that the round is a ritual, and the answers get vaguer every week. So sort them the next day into three kinds.

Story wishes are prep handed to you: "I want to find out what happened to my brother", "more of the harbour politics". Put them on the list you prep from. One wish picked up per session is enough for the table to notice. Spotlight wishes are about a character getting room: note who has not had a scene lately and build one. Table wishes are about how you play, shorter fights or fewer rules arguments or starting on time, and those need a two-minute conversation with everyone at the start of the next session, not a silent adjustment.

Some wishes conflict, and some you will not grant. Say so, briefly, next time: "two of you asked for more dungeon and two for more town, so we are alternating". A wish that was heard and declined does no damage. One that vanishes does.

Stars are worth keeping as well. A list of what this particular table loved is the best description you will ever have of the game they want.

D&D feedback questions for when everyone says it was fine

Quiet tables answer open questions with "it was good". Ask narrower ones, a different one each week, and you will get real answers from the same people.

  • Which scene tonight would you have cut short?
  • Which NPC do you want to see again?
  • Was the fight too long, too short, or about right?
  • What does your character want that the game has not given them a chance at?
  • What should we do more of, less of, and keep the same?
  • Was there a moment you were not sure what you were allowed to do?
  • What are you hoping happens next session?

A D&D player survey for what nobody says out loud

Some things do not get said to a friend’s face in front of four other people: that combat is boring, that one player talks over everyone, that the tone has drifted somewhere uncomfortable. An anonymous survey is the tool for those. Send it every ten sessions or so and at the end of an arc, keep it to what fits on one screen, and use any free form tool with names switched off.

Tell the table what you did with the last one before you send the next. A survey nobody hears back from is the same problem as a wish that vanishes.

Player survey (paste into a form tool; keep it anonymous)

CAMPAIGN CHECK-IN (anonymous, five minutes)

1. Combat, roleplay, exploration:
   which do you want MORE of?  which LESS?
2. Sessions are:  too short / about right / too long
3. How often does your character get a real moment?
   every session / most / some / rarely
4. The best session so far was ____ because ____
5. One NPC, place or plot thread you want to come back:
6. One thing that slows the game down for you:
7. Is there anything at the table (content, rules,
   how we treat each other) you would like handled
   differently?
8. Anything else:

Stars and Wishes, Roses and Thorns, or a debrief: which to use

Use Stars and Wishes every session. It is quick, it is kind, and it produces prep. Its weakness is the one its critics name: it is gentle, and a wish can be too polite to carry a real problem.

So ask for the harder version when you need it. The post that introduced Stars and Wishes describes a GM who uses both, saving Roses and Thorns for the last session of a series when he wants to know plainly what did not work. That is a good rule for D&D too: wishes weekly, direct criticism at the end of an arc, when you ask for it and are ready to hear it. A longer debrief, a conversation with no dice and no time limit, belongs at the midpoint and the end of a campaign.

The same post describes bookending: a wish at the start of the session for what people hope happens tonight, and stars at the end. It works well for a table that meets rarely, because the opening wish tells you what each player remembers caring about.

None of these replaces a conversation about a real problem. If one player is making the game worse for another, a wish round is not where that gets fixed. Table friction needs you to talk to the person.

Feedback for online and text games

On a call, the round works as written; go in the order names appear on screen so nobody has to wonder whose turn it is. For a table that scatters the moment the session ends, post the card in the group chat and ask for answers before the next session. Written answers are slower and usually more thoughtful, and the quiet player who says nothing on a call will often write three lines.

If the campaign runs on a Discord server, give the round its own thread after each session’s recap, so the wishes sit beside the night they were about. Running D&D on Discord has a channel layout that leaves room for it.

Keeping the answers

A wish said aloud at eleven at night is gone by the weekend unless it is written down. Keep one running list for the campaign: the date, the player, the wish in their words, and later what you did about it. Read it before you prep. It is a better guide to the next session than anything you could invent, for the same reason the "what do you want to do next time" answer in the end-of-session ritual is.

If you record your sessions, leave the recording running through the round, and say each player’s name with their wish: a transcript does not know who is speaking. The wishes are then in the record without anyone having to write while they listen.

Where Stars and Wishes comes from, with sources

Every third-party figure quoted above, with where it came from and when it was checked. Prices move — if a date here is old, verify before relying on it.

WhatValueSource
Where Stars and Wishes comes from"Stars and Wishes", by Lu Quade, The Gauntlet Blog, 22 August 2018: "a simple tool that encourages positive feedback and gentle forward-looking criticism"sourceas of 2026-11-13
How the round worksAt the end of a session everyone who played, the facilitator included, "offers a Star to another player, to a moment in the game, or to an element of the overall experience"; then "Each player tells the table something they would like to see happen in a future session"sourceas of 2026-11-13
Why wishes and not thornsIntroduced "in response to negative experiences I had using Roses & Thorns"; "Wishes are forward facing: an optimistic request for change"sourceas of 2026-11-13
Variations described in the same postBookending: "Make a Wish for the upcoming session at the beginning of play, stars as usual at the end"; one GM "uses both Stars and Wishes and Roses and Thorns, as he personally desires stronger criticism at the end of a series"sourceas of 2026-11-13
Wider adoptionThe post’s 2020 update: "It was recently included in the excellent TTRPG Safety Toolkit - compiled by Kienna Shaw and Lauren Bryant-Monk - which won a Gold Ennie for Best Free Game/Product"sourceas of 2026-11-13

How we sourced this: All five rows quote the post that introduced the tool, read on the date shown; the award is reported as that post’s own 2020 update states it, and we did not check it against the awards’ site. The advice on running the round at a D&D table, the feedback questions and the survey are ours, not the post’s.

Related guides

All guides