Tavern Scribe vs DM Scribe: silver per hour against monthly hours
Tavern Scribe is a direct competitor: you record a session or upload the audio, and it writes the recap and keeps the campaign’s characters, quests and timeline up to date. It also gives you a free campaign workspace and a virtual tabletop that we do not have. The real difference is how the AI part is paid for: silver bought in packs and spent by the hour, against our monthly hours with a free plan that does not expire.
The short version
If you want one free place to run the whole campaign (notes, maps, a virtual tabletop, a Discord bot) and only pay when you want an AI recap, Tavern Scribe is built for that and we are not. If you record most sessions and want the recap every time, our plans cost less per hour at their middle and top quality tiers, and our free plan refills every month instead of starting from one 100-silver grant.
The numbers, with sources
| What | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Tavern Scribe — free workspace | Manual campaign management free, “with unlimited characters, quests, notes, maps, live sessions, and audio uploads” | sourceas of 2026-11-15 |
| Tavern Scribe — free AI allowance | “Your first campaign starts with 100 free silver for AI processing, with no subscription required” | sourceas of 2026-11-15 |
| Tavern Scribe — silver packs | $10 for 100; $22.50 for 250; $51 for 600; $120 for 1,500. Silver never expires | sourceas of 2026-11-15 |
| Tavern Scribe — subscriptions | “Additional silver is available by monthly subscription ($10–$100/month)” | sourceas of 2026-11-15 |
| Tavern Scribe — AI rates | Per hour of session audio: Goblin Scribe 21 silver (14 minimum), Human Scribe 40 (25 minimum), Elven Scribe 100 (60 minimum); video uploads 1.5x the audio rate | sourceas of 2026-11-15 |
| Tavern Scribe — inputs | Record on its virtual tabletop or with its Discord bot, or upload audio or video | sourceas of 2026-11-15 |
| Tavern Scribe — systems | “Built for D&D, Pathfinder, Daggerheart, Call of Cthulhu, and any TTRPG system” | sourceas of 2026-11-15 |
| DM Scribe — plans | Free: 2.5 hours/month + one-time 3 bonus hours; $7.99/month for 10 hours; $14.99/month for 30 hours | DM Scribe pricingas of 2026-11-15 |
How we sourced this: Every Tavern Scribe row was read on its own site on 2026-11-15. The pricing page lists the monthly subscriptions without rendering how much silver each includes, so we quote only the price range their own llms.txt states and do not compare the subscriptions to our plans. The per-hour dollar figures in the prose are our arithmetic from the pack prices and rates above. File formats and length limits are not stated on the pages we read, so none are quoted.
How Tavern Scribe charges for AI recaps
Tavern Scribe separates the campaign from the AI. Managing a campaign by hand is free: its pricing page lists unlimited characters, quests, notes, maps, live sessions and audio uploads. The AI processing that turns a recording into a recap is paid in silver, an in-app currency. Your first campaign starts with 100 free silver.
Silver comes in one-time packs, from $10 for 100 to $120 for 1,500, or by monthly subscription, which their own site prices at $10 to $100 a month. You then choose one of three AI quality tiers per session: Goblin Scribe at 21 silver an hour, Human Scribe at 40 and Elven Scribe at 100, each with a session minimum. Video uploads cost 1.5 times the audio rate. Silver never expires and works in any campaign you are in, and players can chip into a shared campaign pool so the game master is not paying for every recap alone.
Every figure here is in the dated table at the end of this page, with the page it came from.
What a session costs on each
This is our arithmetic from their published prices, not a figure Tavern Scribe states. At the $10 pack rate, 100 silver is $10, so an hour costs about $2.10 at Goblin Scribe, $4.00 at Human Scribe and $10.00 at Elven Scribe. The largest pack takes about 20% off those numbers. A three-hour session at Human Scribe is therefore roughly $9.60 to $12.00 depending on which pack you bought.
Our paid plans are $7.99 a month for 10 hours and $14.99 for 30, so a fully used plan works out to about $0.80 or $0.50 an hour. Hours that go unused in a month do not carry over, which is the cost of our model: a table that plays once a month uses a fraction of what it paid for. Our free plan is 2.5 hours a month, with 3 bonus hours at signup, and it refills every month.
So the shape decides it. A table that wants a recap only now and then, or is happy with the cheapest AI tier, will often pay less with Tavern Scribe’s packs. A table that records every weekly session will usually pay less with a monthly plan.
One more difference is how each product treats a file that is not just audio. They charge 1.5 times the audio rate for video. We take video files such as MP4, MOV and MKV at the same hourly rate as audio and keep only the sound track. We also import a transcript you already have as text, which uses none of your hours.
Where the two products overlap
Both turn a recorded session into a written recap. Both keep a campaign reference that updates after each session: their characters, quests, loot and NPCs, against our campaign wiki of NPCs, places and items. Both keep a campaign timeline. Both let you ask questions about earlier sessions, their history search against our Ask Your Campaign, which answers with citations to the sessions it used. Both work with any tabletop RPG, not only D&D; their site names Daggerheart, Pathfinder and Call of Cthulhu.
They have a Discord bot that records a voice channel and a free virtual tabletop that records too. We record in the browser or take an uploaded file, and for a Discord game the usual route is a recording bot such as Craig, whose file you upload.
Where we put the most work is names. Before transcription we build a prompt from your campaign’s glossary, character names and nicknames, and spellings you correct once are applied to every later transcript and recap. We have not tested Tavern Scribe’s output against ours and do not claim either is more accurate.
Pick Tavern Scribe if…
You want the whole campaign in one free place and the AI only when you ask for it. Its core workspace, maps and virtual tabletop cost nothing, and you buy silver only for the sessions you want written up. We do not do the free workspace half at all.
- You play on Discord and want a bot in the voice channel. They have one; we take the file a recording bot makes.
- You want recaps occasionally rather than every session. Silver does not expire, so you pay nothing in a month you do not use it, where our unused hours are gone at the end of the month.
- Your players want to share the cost. Their campaign pool lets players chip in; on our plans the account holder pays.
- You want a virtual tabletop as well as a recap tool. Theirs is free and we have none.
Other comparisons
- World Anvil alternative
World Anvil is built for authoring a world before you play it. Remembering what happened while you did is a different job. Which one you actually need.
- Kanka alternative
Kanka’s free tier, what each paid tier adds, whether it has AI, and self-hosting — from Kanka’s own pages, dated. When do notes from your sessions win?
- LegendKeeper alternative
What LegendKeeper’s free plan can and cannot do, what Pro costs, how the trial works, and when session notes matter more than maps. Which do you need?
- Obsidian and Notion alternative
Obsidian is free and local, Notion is cloud and collaborative, and neither one hears your session. What that actually costs you over a long campaign.
- Otter.ai alternative
Otter caps a conversation at 30 minutes free and 90 on Pro. A D&D session runs four hours. What that costs to fix, with current prices and sources.
- Descript alternative
Descript meters transcription in media minutes; a four-hour D&D session spends 240 of them. How many sessions does each Descript plan really cover?
- Archivist AI alternative
Archivist meters sessions, we meter hours. That one difference decides which is cheaper for your table, and it is not the same answer for everyone.
- The DM's ARK alternative
The DM’s ARK advertises speaker tags; we have none. Its free plan is a trial; ours never expires. Which matters more at your table, and which is cheaper?
- Saga20 alternative
Saga20 recognizes each player’s voice and meters by the session. We meter by the hour. The same table prices out differently — which meter fits yours?
- Tabletop Arc alternative
Tabletop Arc meters audio in minutes — 30 free, 300 for $9. A four-hour session is 240. Whose meter fits your table, and where does Arc genuinely win?
- GM Assistant alternative
GM Assistant sells hours as credits and labels speakers from per-player tracks, which we cannot. Which costs less for a weekly four-hour game?
- Loreify alternative
Loreify sells unlimited sessions for $15 a month or two for $7; we sell hours. How long and how often you play decides which is cheaper. Which are you?
- SessionKeeper alternative
SessionKeeper prices by active campaigns from $3.99 a month, with no free plan listed; we price by hours and have one. Which fits your table?